Betty Ragan wrote:
> Sally Manton wrote:
>
> > It's also very forced, which prompts me to suggest - since
> we *can't* simply
> > cite Bad Writer Syndrome - that it's more for a reaction
> for each other's
> > benefit, as part of the sort-of-mending-fences 'pax' thing
> indicated by
> > Avon's open-hand gesture, than anything to do with Vila.
>
> I've *always* interpreted that scene that way. For one thing, any
> issues of appropriateness or hurtfulness-to-Vila aside, Avon's comment
> *isn't* particularly witty or amusing, certainly not enough to deserve
> that kind of a reaction on its own merits. But it serves as an excuse
> for Blake and Avon to indulge in that shared moment of laughter. I
> don't think it *is* about Vila at all: it's about Blake and Avon
> negotiating a badly-needed emotional rapprochement in one of the few
> ways they're actually capable of doing so. IMHO, of course.
I'd agree - it's a way of defusing tension between Blake and Avon, and I
suppose a Delta's feelings aren't that important to anyone else anyway, and
at this point Vila's very resilient. I don't think anyone but Cally, a
couple of times, ever considered Vila's feelings. And even she joins in the
inexcusable Vila-bashing after Chenga which I'm sure made Tarrant and Dayna
despise him from then on. I've never forgiven Avon for that - insulting Vila
while he was unconscious, then again later - obviously the two latest Alphas
on board would consider him fair game after that.
I think the worst B7 example of what I call the 'tinkly bits' (based on the
tinkly music that Star Trek TOS used to indicate a bit of comic relief) is
at the end of 'Children of Auron'. An entire race has been almost destroyed
and Avon cracks that terrible joke and they all laugh. I just cringed.
<<
DAYNA: What about Cally? Do you think she'll want to go with them?
AVON: Cally will stay with us. We are closer to her than they are. Besides,
a nursery of five thousand, would you want to go with them?
[all laugh, Dayna passes tray, Vila and Tarrant take wafers]
>>
OK, it relieved tension but in such bad taste! At least poor Vila wasn't the
target that time.
Nico
***
This e-mail is privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient please delete the message and notify the sender.
***