David wrote >>
(snipped Kasabi's earthly fertility v. Servalan's earthly sterility)
Harriet >
So you're assuming that the tutelage was on Earth rather than on a space
station or other planet?
David
Yes but not necessarily the entire tutelage - since the story Trooper's
Love by the moderator of this list allows and assumes Kasabi taught
cadets away from Earth - and not in the first instance. It derives from
an earlier assumption. The argument why I am assuming part or all of it
was on Earth runs thus:
1. Servalan is 33-34 in Pressure Point (from EP the Argentine's age at
her death, and from Weapon's 34).
2. Kasabi regretted "not trying to help Servalan" in the beginning (ie.
either at the time they met eachother, or at the start of the period
of Servalan's tutelage. It can be either way, I suppose).
3. Servalan came to a difficult decision when she was 18 or 19 shortly
after Don Keller and before power became her lover (from Sand).
4. While under Kasabi, Servalan informed on Kasabi (from PPt).
5. Veron is 16 (best guess).
6. Veron was born or conceived or both on Earth (an assumption and the
story's raison d'etre as admitted upthread).
These taken together indicate why I am assuming part or all of
Servalan's tutelage was on Earth.
If the reader grants number six above - although, on the one hand it
requires some energy and fiddling to arrange, on the other hand it gives
various benefits in return, eg. Kasabi can have met Hal Mellanby, Bran
Foster, Roj Blake, Del Grant's sister, Dev Tarrant. And if I make
Servalan a cadet before Don Keller, say, aged 16-17, she will have been
the same age as Veron when they met for the first time in Pressure
Point. But if I make Servalan a cadet after Don Keller, say, five years
before Egrorian leaves Bellhangria University, at age 20, then she can
very well be spoilt, idle, vicious, greedy, and sick.
Servalan is not fertile, I say. Kasabi is fertile and on Earth at the
beginning of Veron's existence (either when she became pregnant or when
she delivered or both). To make things equal, to provide a contrast
between the two, Servalan must also be on Earth at some point
(preferably with Don Keller although the story may well go in another
direction). If I don't place Servalan on Earth at some point, I cannot
then turn around and say Servalan is infertile and Kasabi fertile,
because someone will say:
Of course not, since Kasabi was on Earth and Servalan was not.
Put the woman on Earth in her younger days, then you can draw a
contrast.
DC