Steve Kilbane wrote
Me, then Jenny.
That
makes "correct" something that can be difficult to pin down.
Not at all. B7 was production line TV not a film. In a lot of films
things
are changed all the time. Why do you think Live and Let Die is so full
of
holes? But not in TV. You compare an original script with the version
you
see on TV and the changes will be minimal.
You've just agreed that that the product process has an effect, and that the writer's vision isn't the only one.
Only in your head Steve. The way an actor says something, the way a director wants them to say it, the visual design all have an effect, but they don't change the script. Therefore what the writer says goes.
Which means you've got at least
two versions of correct
No. You have one version of correct. An actor has to say the line he's given.
- the writer's, and that of anyone who modifies
the writer's - which immediately leads to two starting points for interpretation.
He may emphasise the line in a particular way. This does not modify the line.
The TV versus film comparison is irrevelant:
No it isn't.
to paraphrase you, one changes
a lot, while the other changes a little.
Scriptwise.
So they both involve change. So
there are multiple viewpoints to start from.
Wrong again Steve. You are living in a dream world.
Jenny
_________________________________________________________________________ Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com.
Jenny,
Please stop insulting my friends. Thank you.
Iain
-
Iain Coleman -
Jenny Kaye