Some time ago (I'm trying to catch up, as always) Alison posted some interesting observations on the existance or lack of moral centre in B7.
It occured to me that 'decentring' is one of the crucial motifs in B7. To begin with, the centre of evil is not where Blake expects it to be, but somewhere else - Central Control has been removed to an unknown location. Almost observing the little Derridian paradox, 'the totality has its centre elsewhere; the centre is not the centre.' By implication, the evil is not *just* where we expect it to be: we have to abandon the original simplified dichotomy (Blake & rebellion = good, the Federation = bad) and replace it by something much more complex and disturbing. The evil is also the 'unseen other' of Our Heroes, present even in the more virtuous of the lot: in Jenna's wavering about the treasure room, in Gan's destructive madness, in Blake's fatal obsession.
Blake, on the other hand, remains the moral centre of the story, although this notion is also challenged and subverted throughout S2. When he's gone in S3, 'decentring' morality becomes even more obvious. Paul Darrow mentions in an interview that he was told by the writers, 'We think now that Blake's gone you ought to be a little more moral', which he obviously refused. In the Programme Guide, Tony Attwood observes about Cally, 'she often took a strong moral line with the crew, particularly after the disappearance of Blake.' Cally is, however, very often removed from the centre of action. Her exchange with Tarrant re Shrinker is a graphic example. Think what Blake would do in a similar situation - probably rush in like a bulldozer and physically prevent the others from mistreating a prisoner. Blake symbolized the powerful presence of morality in one's consciousness; Cally is that same morality reduced to a little voice at the back of one's mind - which, it turns out, is quite easy to ignore. This episode is disturbing on a larger scale, too, as we learn that the rebellion also used Shrinker's services to interrogate prisoners.
Cally's death cry for Blake is perhaps her last attempt to invoke this absent principle of humanity and goodness. By finding Blake eventually, Avon finds his lost moral centre only to destroy it for good. Blake's own morality is made questionable by this final episode, too - by his inability to tell friend from foe, to tell who's Federation and who isn't, which, in a way, implies that he has lost his clear insight into the nature of good and evil. B7 obviously toys with the 'uncertainty principle', probably not because of any conscoius interaction with deconstructionism, but simply because they both reflect our age.
N.
Natasa wrote:
Some time ago (I'm trying to catch up, as always) Alison posted some interesting observations on the existance or lack of moral centre in
B7.
It occured to me that 'decentring' is one of the crucial motifs in B7.
I'm miles behind too, thanks to rotten RSI, but I thought this was a great post, and I've been mulling it over since you posted.
Blake, on the other hand, remains the moral centre of the story,
although
this notion is also challenged and subverted throughout S2. When he's
gone
in S3, 'decentring' morality becomes even more obvious.
[snip]
Tony Attwood observes about Cally, 'she often took a strong moral line with the crew, particularly after the disappearance
of
Blake.' Cally is, however, very often removed from the centre of
action. Her
exchange with Tarrant re Shrinker is a graphic example. Think what
Blake
would do in a similar situation - probably rush in like a bulldozer
and
physically prevent the others from mistreating a prisoner. Blake
symbolized
the powerful presence of morality in one's consciousness; Cally is
that same
morality reduced to a little voice at the back of one's mind - which,
it
turns out, is quite easy to ignore. This episode is disturbing on a
larger
scale, too, as we learn that the rebellion also used Shrinker's
services to
interrogate prisoners.
I can't resist chipping in in support of Cally, and that scene. I've blathered on many, many times about how that scene utterly grabbed me as a kid. I think Cally is brilliant in that scene - hits them with the truth and it *bites*. It's effective as well, isn't it? They *do* stop mistreating Shrinker (well, until Avon murders him).
But you're dead right that Cally removes herself throughout this episode. She has a real dilemma, and I think she's very conflicted throughout. She struggles repeatedly to express to Avon that what he is doing is murder, and thus wrong. But, I think she's finding it difficult to resolve the issue, and that part of what's going on is trying to justify to herself the fact that - by her inactivity - she is effectively letting him go through with it. Bearing in mind her own experience of people like Shrinker during S-L-D, I think part of her thinks he's justified. The only internal resolution she can find is removing herself from the action - just like Auron did.
Of course, I think this just supports your thesis about the decentred morality in B7 .
Una
In message 043001c1467a$ef8faed0$0c00a8c0@codex, Una McCormack una@qresearch.org.uk writes
But you're dead right that Cally removes herself throughout this episode. She has a real dilemma, and I think she's very conflicted throughout. She struggles repeatedly to express to Avon that what he is doing is murder, and thus wrong. But, I think she's finding it difficult to resolve the issue, and that part of what's going on is trying to justify to herself the fact that - by her inactivity - she is effectively letting him go through with it. Bearing in mind her own experience of people like Shrinker during S-L-D, I think part of her thinks he's justified. The only internal resolution she can find is removing herself from the action - just like Auron did.
I think that part of her problem is that she can just about countenance Avon seeking personal revenge on the person who killed his girlfriend. She doesn't approve, she won't actively help him, she'll try to talk him out of it, but she won't actually stop him. But the others do not have personal reasons for hating Shrinker himself - they're simply using him as a means to vent their emotions about the system he's part of. That *isn't* justifiable, in her moral system, and it puts even more pressure on her as to whether Avon's behaviour is in any way justifiable.