In a message dated 2/15/01 8:35:03 AM Eastern Standard Time, stephend999@yahoo.co.uk writes:
<< > Actually, we're on that subject, can anybody think of a god who isn't either male or female? I can't, off the top of my head, except a vague recollection that the Hebrew word translated as "God" in the King James Version of Genesis I is actually plural (which still doesn't make it neuter, and my
recollection may not be > accurate...)<<
Your recollection is accurate. "Elohim", the Hebrew word for god, is actually plural, which for many anthropologists and historians is evidence of the multi-diety origin of Judaism/Christianity. A lot of long-suppressed evidence is starting to surface in the Middle East that the Yawah of the ancient Jews had a female counterpart, without whom he could not function; Ashera. The later turn of the faith toward domination by the patriarchs demonized and eradicated her, reducing her presence down to nothing more than the feminine 'aspect' of God as a whole, the "Shechina."
An intermittant movement or two arose through the subsequent 3 millennia to restore the presence of Ashera (sometimes through arcane Kaballah interpretation), but were always suppressed; by then, both Christianity and Judaism were solidly entrenched in their Patriarchal domination.
You could make a very respectable case for the Christian deity !
Certainly, once you start envisaging God as having "neither body, parts nor passions" it tends to militate against God having any sex/gender. This hasn't of course stopped people referring to God as "he". I think feminist theologians would argue that this is a hangover from patriarchy rather than saying anything about God's nature.<<
Unfortunately, Judeao-Christian theologians have historically used the strict characterization of God as a literal male to turn the female half of their number into second-class members of the faith, still unworthy of clerical priesthood and needing to yeild obedience to a man because he does not carry the burden of that nasty sin with the apple, back in the Garden of Eden. What amazes me is our continued compliance with these ideas, 3 THOUSAND years later. Sometimes, I don't think the dark ages actually ended.
I would guess that most deities are given personal
attributes which would include sex/ gender. As always I am open to correction from anyone who knows different. (Did Plato refer to God as "He", I can't remember off the top of my head).<<
Patriarchal religion began to replace the almost universal Goddess religions when agriculture and city-states kicked in big time, about 3,000 years ago. In multi-god cultures like Greece and Rome, the 'chief' diety became an all-powerful male one. It's no coincidence that this was around about the time that it became general knowledge, for the first time, that the male had a part in the procreation process.
Leah
--- Bizarro7@aol.com wrote: >
Unfortunately, Judeao-Christian theologians have historically used the strict characterization of God as a literal male to turn the female half of their number into second-class members of the faith,
I'm not sure about the term 'literal male'. But I wouldn't deny that the use of male language about God has historically underpinned patriarchal attitudes.
still unworthy of clerical priesthood and needing to yeild obedience to a man because he does not carry the burden of that nasty sin with the apple, back in the Garden of Eden.
I think that depends which Christians or Jews you ask.
What amazes me is our continued compliance with
these
ideas, 3 THOUSAND years later. Sometimes, I don't think the dark ages actually ended.
I wouldn't (in this forum at least) want to argue any point more controversial than the idea that if you concieve God as being timeless and eternal it is rather silly to refer to God as being male in any meaningful sense of the word. I agree that such silliness has underpinned a great deal of injustice in the past and present.
Stephen.
____________________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Get your free @yahoo.co.uk address at http://mail.yahoo.co.uk or your free @yahoo.ie address at http://mail.yahoo.ie
About the gender of deities: 1. Some gods are gendered but not human beings, e.g., the Indian deity who is an elephant 2. I think that to a Christian who believes in the Holy Trinity, the Father and the Son are male but the Holy Spirit is neither male nor female
-(Y)
--- Dana Shilling dshilling@worldnet.att.net wrote:
About the gender of deities:
- Some gods are gendered but not human beings,
e.g., the Indian deity who is an elephant
a) No, but they're still gendered(and btw, that goes for hermaphrodites too, they're just gender advantaged)
b) As I understand it, Ganesha is half-human; a boy with an elephant head, rather than an actual elephant.
Fiona
The Posthumous Memoirs of Secretary Rontane Available for public perusal at http://nyder.r67.net
____________________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Get your free @yahoo.co.uk address at http://mail.yahoo.co.uk or your free @yahoo.ie address at http://mail.yahoo.ie
--- Bizarro7@aol.com wrote: > In a message dated 2/15/01 8:35:03 AM Eastern
multi-diety origin of Judaism/Christianity. A lot of long-suppressed evidence is starting to surface in the Middle East that the Yawah of the ancient Jews had a female counterpart, without whom he could not function; Ashera. The later turn of the faith toward domination by the patriarchs demonized and eradicated her, reducing her presence down to nothing more than the feminine 'aspect' of God as a whole, the "Shechina."
An intermittant movement or two arose through the subsequent 3 millennia to restore the presence of Ashera (sometimes through arcane Kaballah interpretation), but were always suppressed; by then, both Christianity and Judaism were solidly entrenched in their Patriarchal domination.
Interesting-- is there any link between this and the movement in feminist Jewish scholarship to rehabilitate Lilith?
Fiona
The Posthumous Memoirs of Secretary Rontane Available for public perusal at http://nyder.r67.net
____________________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Get your free @yahoo.co.uk address at http://mail.yahoo.co.uk or your free @yahoo.ie address at http://mail.yahoo.ie