Louise wrote:
Doesn't seem to vary a great deal from the favourite eps lists of people on this Lyst, although I think City normally scores more highly here and the inclusion of Sand comes as something of a surprise. Gambit should have been there instead.
Truth to tell, I rather like Sand, mainly for its atmospheric sets, not to mention Avon's horror at Orac's declaration of love. I also rate Sarcophagus highly, though I know a lot of fans hate it. I can only say, I loved it when I first saw it. I remember trying to work out what the dreamlike opening sequence meant, in relation to the rest of the episode. The writer, Tanith Lee, was something of a fan herself I believe, and produced a fine fantasy novel with openly ackowledged avatars or Vila and Avon. I bought it in paperback in 1980 from a small independant shop called Fantast (Medway). Anyone else heard of it? The owner produced a book list/review of his stock to anyone interested for the annual sum of a quid, I think, and was extremely friendly and informative to anyone who dropped into his shop. Returning to B7, favourite episode lists are extremely subjective. I think it depends on the elements of the episodes in question which the individual focusses on as significant. I'm rather fond of Moloch, though I know it can hardly be classed as a top piece of writing. I remember a long-ago Horizon club questionaire on S3 where in my reply I mentioned the scene between Avon and Dayna concerning the dead mouse and the apple. That scene just happened to be a favourite of mine. Moloch is not a 'great' episode, but it still entertains me in lots of ways. I generally try to look for the good points in an episode before the bad.
Mel
--- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.313 / Virus Database: 174 - Release Date: 1/2/02
Mel Saxby wrote:
Truth to tell, I rather like Sand, mainly for its atmospheric sets, not to mention Avon's horror at Orac's declaration of love. I also rate
Sarcophagus
highly, though I know a lot of fans hate it. I can only say, I loved it
when
I first saw it. I remember trying to work out what the dreamlike opening sequence meant, in relation to the rest of the episode. The writer, Tanith Lee, was something of a fan herself I believe, and produced a fine fantasy novel with openly acknowledged avatars or Vila and Avon. I bought it in paperback in 1980 from a small independent shop called Fantast (Medway). Anyone else heard of it?
Do you mean 'Kill the Dead'? I bought it recently after hearing about it on the Lyst and enjoyed it very a lot--much more in fact than 'Sarcophagus' or 'Sand', neither of which would appear among my favourites.
Returning to B7, favourite episode lists are extremely subjective. I think it depends on the elements of the episodes in question which the individual focuses on as significant. I'm rather fond of Moloch, though I know it can hardly be classed as a top piece of writing. I remember a long-ago Horizon club questionnaire on S3 where in my reply I mentioned
the
scene between Avon and Dayna concerning the dead mouse and the apple. That scene just happened to be a favourite of mine. Moloch is not a 'great' episode, but it still entertains me in lots of ways. I generally try to
look
for the good points in an episode before the bad.
I agree. There are scenes I like a lot from 'Moloch' (Vila and Servalan) and 'Power' (Pella and Vila) while I dislike intensely other parts of these eps, esp. those showing Ben Steed's sexism. I must say I can't think of much to like about 'Harvest of Kairos', although some of it is unintentionally very funny. 'Animals' on the other hand is the only B7 ep I fast-forwarded.
Nico
In message 001f01c1a6bd$6303aea0$c985403e@harsharin, Mel Saxby harsharin@lineone.net writes
Truth to tell, I rather like Sand, mainly for its atmospheric sets, not to mention Avon's horror at Orac's declaration of love. I also rate Sarcophagus highly, though I know a lot of fans hate it. I can only say, I loved it when I first saw it. I remember trying to work out what the dreamlike opening sequence meant, in relation to the rest of the episode. The writer, Tanith Lee, was something of a fan herself I believe, and produced a fine fantasy novel with openly ackowledged avatars or Vila and Avon. I bought it in paperback in 1980 from a small independant shop called Fantast (Medway). Anyone else heard of it?
_Kill the Dead_, and it's fairly well-known on this list, although it appears to be out of print in both the US and the UK editions.
Tanith Lee was a big fan of B7 when it was first broadcast, according to an interview with her sometime around 1983 (for those who've asked, I've finally managed to resuscitate my backup CDs, so with any luck I'll be able to get at the transcript of it now). Sarcophagus is essentially a piece of fanfic by a pro script writer. Sand less so, because she wasn't available to do the rewrites, and it's more heavily influenced by Chris Boucher.
Sarcophagus is one of those episodes that fans generally either love or hate. I love it, although I can see Chris Boucher's point about not wanting more than one of that style per series.