Mistral wrote:
> Nicola Mody-Nikoloff wrote:
>
> > In her avatar list, Judith mentions a western novel
> ("Darrow's Law") with
> > the two main characters called Darrow and Keating. I
> actually read it out of
> > curiosity and it was pretty light-weight and forgettable,
> but the sheriff
> > and his deputy were definitely Avon and Vila.
>
> Either you're being very kind, or I'm simply too demanding. I went to
> the trouble and expense to order a copy of this from Amazon.co.uk and
> found it to be *the* most unreadable piece of pro-fic I've ever
> encountered. Nobody in this book *says* anything - they all snarl, or
> spit, or expostulate it - and the sentence rhythms are atrocious and
> grating. I tossed it away in disgust after only a cursory skim. Trying
> to salvage the expense, I loaned it to my dad, who goes
> through westerns
> the way some people go through chocolates, and even he couldn't finish
> it.
>
> On the upside, after trying to read _Darrow's Law_, I was able to view
> my own fanfic with a somewhat less jaundiced eye. But consider this a
> plea for anyone who's interested in reading it to try to borrow it, or
> get it on interlibrary loan; don't waste your money. It is,
> IMO, beyond dreadful.
Yep, I was being kind. I hate to bad-mouth someone else's writing (maybe I'm
scared of criticism myself), but I do wonder sometimes how some books get
published.
Nico
***
This e-mail is privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient please delete the message and notify the sender.
***